I was actually pleasantly surprised with the graphics in this game, knowing that NFL Blitz usually doesn't put that much into making the graphics look believable. The players and stadiums have realism that rivals Triple Play and other simulation baseball games. For instance, in Veterans Stadium in Philadelphia, you can see the worn down outline of the football field from Eagles games! The players look almost like the real players. Even for a game that is meant to be 'extreme,' its graphics contend with the mainstay titles in baseball.
The announcers for Slugfest are up to par with most sports games. As with all sports commentary on video games, they get very repetitive after you've played the game for longer than an hour. The commentary on Slugfest is very funny at times, however. I didn't see any issues with the commentary not matching up with the play on the field, which is more than I can say for some other games. They do tend to say things like, 'When this guy first came up, everyone talked about the power in his legs,' for everyone from the clean up hitter to the pitcher. The problem comes with the lack of depth of sound bites. The game's music is not outstanding, but the DVD does feature an extra music video from Dry Kill Logic.